I’m often asked how much protein we should
eat, and whether or not protein shakes and supplements are necessary. Whilst I
have personal experience of this in relation to endurance sports, I thought I’d
do a little more research into it. So here’s what I have dug up;
The UK government states that
per day adults need 0.75g per kg we weigh. So if you weigh 60kg (which is
about 132 pounds, or 9 stone 6 pound), you would require 45g protein per day.
The chart below summarises total grams per day for different categories of
people.
Age
|
g/kg/d
|
For average weight g/d:
|
0-3 months
|
2.12
|
12.5 (baby weighing
5.9kg/13lb)
|
4-6 months
|
1.6
|
12.7 (baby weighing
7.7kg/17lb)
|
4 – 6 years
|
1.11
|
19.7 (child weighing
17.8kg/2st11lb)
|
15 -18 years (boys)
|
0.86
|
55.2 (boy weighing 64.5kg/10st2lb)
|
15-18 years (girls)
|
0.82
|
45.4 (girl weighing
55.5kg/8st10lb)
|
19+ years (men and women)
|
0.75
|
45.0 (woman weighing
60kg/9st6lb)
|
In pregnancy
|
|
an extra 6 g per day
|
Breastfeeding
|
|
an extra 8 to 11 g per day
|
(Reference: Report on Health
and Social Subjects 41 Dietary Reference Values for Food Energy and Nutrients
for the UK)
Most people in the UK easily consume
adequate quantities of protein in their diet to fulfill these health
requirements.
But here’s the question: for a healthy
individual already achieving relatively high protein intakes from diet alone,
is there any merit in advocating additional supplementation?
Is more better?
Eating more than the
recommended protein intake offers no benefits. Apart from being costly, a
protein-based diet commonly displaces important carbohydrates from the diet.
That is, if you have an omelet and a protein shake for breakfast instead of
cereal with banana, you'll consume fewer carbs to fuel your muscles properly.
If you consume too much
protein from supplements, you may also fail to invest in optimal health. Displacing
natural foods with engineered foods (such as protein supplements) limits your
intake of the vegetables, fruits, grains, fiber, phytochemicals, natural
vitamins and other health-protective nutrients that nature puts in whole foods.
I've heard I should eat a protein
bar for a pre-exercise snack?
It’s well established that a sufficient
protein intake is necessary to see the full extent of benefits from a
resistance training program. Dietary protein increases post-exercise muscle
protein synthesis rates and inhibits muscle protein breakdown, allowing
enhanced muscle protein growth during the post-exercise recovery period. Hence
body builders routinely take protein supplements with good results.
Pre-exercise protein digests
into amino acids that are then ready and waiting to be taken up by the muscles
after a strength workout.
This does not mean you'll
evolve into Charles Atlas; you'll simply optimize your body's ability to build
and repair muscle at that moment. To build muscle you need to engage in a
progressive resistance training program.
Why do you need
to eat protein or drink protein shakes after exercising?
Protein shakes and powders
carry a certain allure, but your muscles don’t care if the protein comes from a
hard-boiled egg, glass of chocolate milk or whey protein shake. 10 to 20 grams
of protein is all you need to provide amino acids (the building blocks of
protein) to muscles.
Carbohydrate
Plus Protein Speeds Recovery
Research also
shows that combining protein with carbohydrate within thirty minutes of
exercise nearly doubles the insulin response, which results in more stored
glycogen. The optimal carbohydrate to protein ratio for this effect is 4:1
(four grams of carbohydrate for every one gram of protein). Eating more protein
than that, however, has a negative impact because it slows rehydration and
glycogen replenishment.
One study found that
athletes who refueled with carbohydrate and protein had 100 percent greater
muscle glycogen stores than those who only ate carbohydrate. Insulin was also
highest in those who consumed a carbohydrate and protein drink.
With so many sports drinks, bars, and more to choose from, how do you
make the best choices?
A good sports drink contains 14-15 grams of
carbohydrate in 8 ounces. It should also contain about 110 milligrams of sodium
and 30 milligrams of potassium in the same volume.
Look for energy bars that contain about 5
grams of protein, with some carbohydrate (preferably with more naturally
occurring sugars) and very little fat. Many energy bars are just glorified,
expensive candy bars, so remember that "energy" means calories and
watch out for high-calorie bars. They are helpful for athletes on the go, so if
you can't eat before a long tennis match, an energy bar can help.
Choose protein powders made from whey protein or
milk proteins (milk protein contains two types of proteins, both whey and
casein). Use them within 30 minutes after exercising to provide needed amino
acids to muscles.
The long and short of it
is that unless you are engaging in endurance training or heavy resistance
training, there is no benefit in consuming additional protein in your diet.
No comments:
Post a Comment